The View From The Stars by Walter M. Miller, jr. (1923 – 1996) was first published in 1965. It is a collection of nine short stories all previously published in a variety of genre-related publications. This is his second published collection of short stories. I read his novel A Canticle for Leibowitz and was impressed, but not tremendously so.
If I knew nothing of the author besides what I read in this collection, I would not be surprised if/when you tell me that the author committed suicide. It is clear to me he was “unsettled” even from these writings. I think he took his life after his wife passed away. But allegedly he suffered depression or PTSD, or something. Well, also allegedly he was a USAF bomber who wrecked Monte Cassino…. so I just cannot conjure any sympathy for him. Nevertheless, one of the striking tones that I found in this collection was a depressed and heavy one. Like most good science fiction, Miller asks significant questions about mankind and existence and the future. He examines mankind’s role in the universe in a number of scenarios. Somehow, though, there is also an added heaviness that pervades all of these stories. Miller is not a happy guy.
- You Triflin’ Skunk (1955)
- The Will (1954)
- Anybody Else Like Me (1952)
- Crucifixus Etiam (1953)
- I, Dreamer (1953)
- Dumb Waiter (1952)
- Blood Bank (1952)
- Big Joe and the Nth Generation (1952)
- The Big Hunger (1952)
These stories generally have the grim/dark element of destruction (either individually or on a broad scale) running through them. They are not “uplifting” stories, really. There is a hefty dose of destruction in most of these stories and because of that I was not able to race through them. It is not easy to read heavy material. However, there is a lot more going on than just a darker feeling. Throughout all of the stories is a persistent awareness, questioning, and allusion to religion. Miller is not an irreligious or blasphemous person in these stories. Nevertheless, he does strongly demonstrate his difficulty with creation of man by the Divine. In many stories there is a reference to man having descended directly from ape. There are often comparisons between man and ape.
But Miller also examines mankind’s relationship with technology. Does tech rule man or man rule tech? What is the value of tech? Can man appreciate that value? Is tech to be feared? What about man’s misuse of technology? There are also places whereat he seems to gently pit technology against religion, just to see what happens.
You Triflin’ Skunk – 4 stars – this was my second favorite story in the book. It is very Southern. But its also got this dark humor which is good for late-night reading. I got a kick out of this one. Miller is also displaying his writing skill; the tone is tense, the setting is excellent. One feels pity for the characters and I really enjoyed the ending.
The Will – 2 stars – this was my least favorite in the book. This one contains a solid dose of misery and depression. Despite, I think, its effort at being futuristic and hopeful. I don’t really like reading about dying kids.
Anybody Else Like Me – 2 stars – this story is creative and has a developed suspense factor. However, I feel like the creativity is stifled a bit by a somewhat unrelateable plot. I just wanted more out of the story. The main character did not evoke any sort of sympathy or interest. But I am no fan of such characters…
Crucifixus Etiam – 3 stars – dismal, heavy, sad. Here Miller really wrestles with the concepts of sacrifice, the future of mankind, and planet colonization. Miller asks if the value of goals changes based on its proximity. There are a number of stories in this ilk that come from the 1950s star science fiction writers. However, while this one really makes strong and painful points, it is a heavy read tinged with vague hopelessness.
I, Dreamer – 3 stars – This story is the most dark and dismal of the bunch. This is really a heavy and shocking read. It is also exceedingly well-written – poetic and artistic. Unfortunately, there is the same sad and hopeless feeling as in some of the other stories – though here it is amped up. I really think the writing level is excellent, but I do not think I can give this to many people to read. If anything, this is a story that will stick with me for awhile.
Dumb Waiter – 4 stars – This is my favorite story in the book (and probably most readers’ favorite). It has a very nicely done post-apocalyptic urban/technological story. Math, logic, survival skills all play a role. In places, the tone is as relentless and ruthless as the characters need to be in order to survive. This story is edgy, as they say; gritty. I love anything with robots and computers, of course. But there is one small section that is weird and disturbing. (Hello, why didn’t someone send Miller to a shrink in 1952?) but that can be omitted without loss to the story.
Blood Bank – 3 stars – this is a good story, that might even be great. Here we have the only real “adventure” story in the collection. But even so, this is not mere pulp. Miller uses it to ask any number of questions about evolution, nature, ethical motives, intergalactic politics, and military “virtue.” There is an excellent level of cultural awareness. However, the ending is rather spare and there are places where the story meanders a bit from its main path. Don’t worry, here too is a level of shock and misery.
Big Joe and the Nth Generation – 4 stars – this story is really creative, interesting, and technological. There is a lot of suspense and the story really resonates with the reader. It is like Indiana Jones meets John Carter, I think. “What is a technologist?” – is asked, which is a question that really runs through this whole collection, but only actually voiced here. Once again, elements of sacrifice, religion, and future planet-forming are touched upon.
The Big Hunger – 2 stars – This story did not really do much for me. Maybe because it was predictable – it isn’t so much of a story as a rumination on mankind’s predictability. History is cyclic and repeating. Man is ambitious and stubborn. Man has come from apes. And mainly: what does technology “think” of man? I feel like this has been done in a more interesting way plenty of times – but maybe not with this artistic writing? I get what Miller is doing here, but I just found it droll and preachy.
Therefore, definitely read Dumb Waiter and Big Joe and the Nth Generation. If you still want more, read You Triflin’ Skunk. Other than that, this is somewhat too dismal for me to recommend openly to all.