Mistborn was published in 2006. This is the first in Brandon Sanderson’s Mistborn series, which is set in the world Scadrial. It is the second Sanderson novel that I have read. This review is one that I have procrastinated writing for several months. Unfortunately, due to my procrastination, some of the more detailed commentary I might have been inclined to write about has passed from my memory. However, some of the reason for my procrastination is exactly because I did not care to get into the details with this novel.
The question is obviously: well, why was I avoiding the detailed review? Mainly, because I very much feel like this is an entertaining novel that does not need to be picked apart with a fine-toothed comb. It is a novel that does not deserve to be examined under the critic’s most powerful microscope. Most important, I simply do not want to dig into the details of this novel.
Since this novel is such a popular novel, I am certain there are thousands of reviews and opinions that have already been given on it – and delve into all of its aspects from a multitude of perspectives. So, I certainly have nothing much to add in that respect anyway.
This is a Regency Romance with Allomancy and societal class struggle. If you think that that sounds like an interesting mash-up, by all means, pick up this novel and read it and enjoy the heck out it! If you do not – literally, if any of that sounds awful – then do not read it and also do not rant online about it.
In a lot of ways, this novel felt, to me, like a rewrite or a remix of Elantris. And that is okay because I enjoyed Elantris, for the most part. I did feel, as I read Mistborn, that Sanderson had taken people and places and moved them from the world of Raoden and Sarene to Scadrial – also giving them the necessary make-overs to present similar but different people. This is not a bad thing – there are a lot of fun “what ifs” out there that explore in similar ways. Readers who have only read these two books, though, might be a little concerned that Sanderson is not capable of anything truly new, even though what he does produce is detailed and well-planned.
The novel does seem, content-wise, to be a bit young adult in style. This is a difficult statement, because back-in-the-day, there were juvenile novels and then there were novels. “Young Adult” wasn’t really a genre. Most people now also have come to conclude that the majority of so-called “young adult” novels are not actually for young adults. So, what to do with this mess? To me, a lot of times it seems that if something is not full-on Grimdark, then readers feel it must be “ya.” This is a lack of nuancing among readership – and likely a problem that authors and publishers wrangle over as well. I do not read novels and say to myself, “Oh boy, this would have been better if there had been a lot more gore, explicit language, and smut!” So, if readers feel this is too clean or easy a read, well, I guess maybe I am not sure what they expect out of the novel. The thing is, the main character, Vin, is a teenager. Likely, she is between 14-17 years old. The perspectives, understandings, and worldview of the novel are going to heavily remain in that age range. Vin is just not going to view the world as a grizzled old man. In other words, well, maybe the “young adult” feel to the novel comes straightforward from the main character being a young adult; go figure.
There are themes here, too, that would be relevant to a young adult. Class struggle, the meaning of friends/family, duty to society, etc. Argument could easily be made that these themes are relevant to all people, but its rather a fact that by 30 most people are stubbonly set in their worldviews. As the storyline progresses, the main character does have a coming-of-age destiny. I think nowadays this is a type of storytelling called “progressive fantasy.” Now, if the reader does not take much of a shine to Vin, this novel will be one heckuva slog, because there is no escape from Vin here.
At times, I did not think this novel would end. I felt like there was a lot of repetitive storytelling going on for awhile, but maybe that is okay, too, because it was not horrible writing. It is a long novel. As I said above, if you want to read a Regency Romance with Allomancy, the length is not going to be a problem for you. For others, it might seem rather slow.
One of the things I did enjoy is the character Sazed and his endless supply of knowledge regarding the religions on Scadrial. It was fun because Sanderson allowed the pluralism of a planet to be understandable and valuable. These moments did not feel forced or strange and it was all done with a good reasonable tone. I liked that a lot. I could sit down and chat with Sazed.
Anyway, Mistborn was an enjoyable read. It was a bit longish and slow at times. But I cannot say that I did not enjoy my time. The magic (allomancy) is relatively interesting and fun – and much better than some magic systems I have come across. All in all this is an entertaining read, good as it is for what it is. No more, no less.
3 stars